Carroll v. Craddock

  • Filed: 03/12/2020
  • Status: Victory!
  • Latest Update: Mar 12, 2020
Placeholder image

This is a federal lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of a state law that gives the DMV Administrator carte blanche authority to deny vanity license plates based on whether he thinks they “might carry connotations offensive to good taste and decency.”

Attorney(s):
Thomas W. Lyons & Rhiannon Huffman

Court Declares Ban on "Offensive" Vanity Plates is Unconstitutional

The judgment comes in a lawsuit filed in March 2020 on behalf of Sean Carroll, an environmentally conscious Tesla owner who was ordered by the DMV to turn in his license plate “FKGAS” or else have his car registration cancelled.

Placeholder image

ACLU Sues DMV Over Ability to Censor “Offensive” Vanity Plates

YOU CAN BE “FATTY” BUT NOT “CHUBBY”; “TIPSY” BUT NOT “DRUNK”; ADVERTISE “HEAVEN” BUT NOT “HELL”; SAY “DOGDOO” BUT NOT “DOOBIE”; BE AN “OLDFRT” BUT NOT A “JOCKY”; AND PROUDLY TRUMPET “FRIAR” BUT NOT “HOOSIER”

Placeholder image

Court Rules That Ban on “Offensive” License Plates Likely Violates First Amendment

A federal judge has issued a preliminary injunction in support of our lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of a state law that gives the DMV Administrator carte blanche authority to deny vanity license plates.

Placeholder image

Related News & Podcasts

News & Commentary
Feb 12, 2021
Placeholder image
  • First Amendment

Court Declares Ban on "Offensive" Vanity Plates is Unconstitutional

The judgment comes in a lawsuit filed in March 2020 on behalf of Sean Carroll, an environmentally conscious Tesla owner who was ordered by the DMV to turn in his license plate “FKGAS” or else have his car registration cancelled.
News & Commentary
Mar 12, 2020
Placeholder image
  • First Amendment

ACLU Sues DMV Over Ability to Censor “Offensive” Vanity Plates

YOU CAN BE “FATTY” BUT NOT “CHUBBY”; “TIPSY” BUT NOT “DRUNK”; ADVERTISE “HEAVEN” BUT NOT “HELL”; SAY “DOGDOO” BUT NOT “DOOBIE”; BE AN “OLDFRT” BUT NOT A “JOCKY”; AND PROUDLY TRUMPET “FRIAR” BUT NOT “HOOSIER”
News & Commentary
Oct 04, 2020
Placeholder image
  • First Amendment

Court Rules That Ban on “Offensive” License Plates Likely Violates First Amendment

A federal judge has issued a preliminary injunction in support of our lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of a state law that gives the DMV Administrator carte blanche authority to deny vanity license plates.