Lombardi and Davis v. Raimondo

  • Filed: 07/03/2019
  • Status: Victory!
  • Latest Update: Jul 03, 2019
Placeholder image

This is a federal lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of a 110-year-old Rhode Island statute that declares inmates serving life sentences at the ACI to be “dead in all respects” with respect to “all civil rights.”

Attorney(s):
Sonja Deyoe, Lynette Labinger

Judge Refuses to Dismiss Lawsuit Challenging Archaic State Law that Deems Inmates Serving Life “Civilly Dead”

“Plaintiffs’ inability to assert civil actions by virtue of this statute burdens their fundamental right of access to the courts because they are unable to challenge the conditions of their confinement, namely, the physical harm they allegedly suffered while confined.”

Placeholder image

ACLU Asks Court to Reject State's Claim that Inmates Serving Life Cannot Challenge Rights Violations

In a brief filed today, the ACLU of Rhode Island has asked the Superior Court to reject a claim made by the R.I. Department of Corrections (DOC) that inmates serving life sentences at the ACI have no legal right to sue for any violation of their civil rights.  In a related letter sent today to Governor Gina Raimondo, the ACLU of RI also asked her to intervene and call upon the DOC to refrain from taking this position in future inmate civil rights lawsuits.

Placeholder image

ACLU Challenges Century-Old Law Declaring Inmates Serving Life Sentences “Civilly Dead”

The ACLU of Rhode Island today filed a federal lawsuit to challenge the constitutionality of a 110-year-old statute that declares inmates serving life sentences at the ACI to be “dead in all respects” with respect to “all civil rights.” The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court by ACLU cooperating attorneys Sonja Deyoe and Lynette Labinger, is on behalf of two ACI inmates who are barred from pursuing legal actions against the Department of Corrections in court because of the “civil death” law. According to the lawsuit, Rhode Island may be the only state in the country still enforcing a law like this, whose origins date back to ancient English common law.

Placeholder image

Related News & Podcasts

News & Commentary
Mar 29, 2021
Placeholder image
  • Criminal Justice|
  • +2 Issues

Judge Refuses to Dismiss Lawsuit Challenging Archaic State Law that Deems Inmates Serving Life “Civilly Dead”

“Plaintiffs’ inability to assert civil actions by virtue of this statute burdens their fundamental right of access to the courts because they are unable to challenge the conditions of their confinement, namely, the physical harm they allegedly suffered while confined.”
News & Commentary
Sep 07, 2017
Placeholder image
  • Due Process|
  • +2 Issues

ACLU Asks Court to Reject State's Claim that Inmates Serving Life Cannot Challenge Rights Violations

In a brief filed today, the ACLU of Rhode Island has asked the Superior Court to reject a claim made by the R.I. Department of Corrections (DOC) that inmates serving life sentences at the ACI have no legal right to sue for any violation of their civil rights.  In a related letter sent today to Governor Gina Raimondo, the ACLU of RI also asked her to intervene and call upon the DOC to refrain from taking this position in future inmate civil rights lawsuits.
News & Commentary
Jul 03, 2019
Placeholder image
  • Criminal Justice|
  • +2 Issues

ACLU Challenges Century-Old Law Declaring Inmates Serving Life Sentences “Civilly Dead”

The ACLU of Rhode Island today filed a federal lawsuit to challenge the constitutionality of a 110-year-old statute that declares inmates serving life sentences at the ACI to be “dead in all respects” with respect to “all civil rights.” The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court by ACLU cooperating attorneys Sonja Deyoe and Lynette Labinger, is on behalf of two ACI inmates who are barred from pursuing legal actions against the Department of Corrections in court because of the “civil death” law. According to the lawsuit, Rhode Island may be the only state in the country still enforcing a law like this, whose origins date back to ancient English common law.