ACLU Calls for Dropping of Felony Charges Against Alleged Columbus Statue Vandals
Posted: June 22, 2020|Category: Criminal Justice Police Practices Right to Petition & Protest
In a letter to police chief Hugh Clements, Jr., the ACLU of Rhode Island has sharply criticized the Providence police department for filing felony charges against three Rhode Islanders who allegedly threw white paint at a boarded-up statue of Christopher Columbus in the Elmwood section of the city. The letter, labeling the charges “deeply troubling,” called for immediate action by the department to have those charges dropped. In the letter, ACLU of RI executive director Steven Brown wrote:
“Rather than being arrested for a misdemeanor offense of vandalism for splashing paint on plywood, all three people were instead charged with two felony offenses that carry a potential maximum sentence of six years in prison. Whether this overcharging was done to make it easier to get the defendants to waive their right to a trial and plead to a misdemeanor or just out of pure malice will likely never be known. What is clear, however, is that the underlying felony charges border on the ridiculous. Specifically, the three individuals have been charged with ‘desecration of [a] grave,’ a statute appearing in a section of the General Laws dealing with ‘Graves and Corpses.’ The second felony charge is for conspiring to commit the first felony.
“In relevant part, the ‘desecration’ statute makes it a felony to willfully and maliciously deface any tomb or monument, or anything intended for the protection of the tomb or monument, that is ‘placed or designed for a memorial of the dead.’ It also authorizes an order of restitution for any ‘expense of repairing the grave.’ The Columbus statue may be many things, but to equate it to monuments found in cemeteries stretches the wording of the state law beyond the breaking point.
“Charging people with crimes should not be a game where points are awarded for coming up with the most serious possible charge imaginable, however far-fetched. While we are confident that these three individuals will never be convicted of this offense, they will always have to live with the fact that they were arrested and charged as felons. This is not justice. It is a blatant abuse of police authority, and one that happens all too often and needs to stop.
“To put this charge in more perspective, it is worth noting that in the past year, two Providence police officers have been charged with assault, one involving allegedly hitting a man several times after he had been handcuffed, and the other a domestic dispute that landed the alleged victim in the hospital. Both officers were charged with misdemeanors.
“This case demonstrates that, as the city, state and country grapple with issues of police accountability, the abuse of the broad discretion that police often have in deciding what charges to lodge against suspects deserves very thorough scrutiny as well.
“We ask that you immediately act to have the felony charges against these three defendants dropped. In addition, we ask that you promptly conduct a thorough review of the Department’s charging practices to prevent further travesties like this from happening.”
The letter was also sent to Providence Public Safety Commissioner Steven Pare and Attorney General Peter Neronha. The ACLU is not representing the individuals on the criminal charges.